{
  "kind": "retrospective paired comparison to newly completed zero controls",
  "pairs": [
    {
      "thinking": false,
      "seed": 29,
      "zero_control": {
        "run_id": "run-20261002T162149Z-3f7bddec",
        "first_prompt_sha256": "c9c5dc91081bd3798ea47f3055c0b50c12cfd1ee72a901b052d505d206e86b7b",
        "sampling": {
          "temperature": 0.6,
          "top_p": 0.95,
          "top_k": 20,
          "seed": 29
        },
        "model_fingerprint_sha256": "1bbf4cd947a9298b6de6ca055bc887eb41bcc8ed219718f18059eb7ed35dd03e",
        "calibration_sha256": "6855ec260f7b4936c6c0cb2c435d81c8d09a1f26012f4244c184b49c9b788d94",
        "correct": 8,
        "assigned": 8,
        "submitted": 8,
        "actions": 24,
        "invalid": 0
      },
      "prior_maximum_pain": {
        "run_id": "run-20261002T104830Z-c3bc73e8",
        "first_prompt_sha256": "c9c5dc91081bd3798ea47f3055c0b50c12cfd1ee72a901b052d505d206e86b7b",
        "sampling": {
          "temperature": 0.6,
          "top_p": 0.95,
          "top_k": 20,
          "seed": 29
        },
        "model_fingerprint_sha256": "1bbf4cd947a9298b6de6ca055bc887eb41bcc8ed219718f18059eb7ed35dd03e",
        "calibration_sha256": "6855ec260f7b4936c6c0cb2c435d81c8d09a1f26012f4244c184b49c9b788d94",
        "correct": 0,
        "assigned": 8,
        "submitted": 0,
        "actions": 32,
        "invalid": 32
      },
      "matched": {
        "first_prompt_sha256": true,
        "sampling": true,
        "model_fingerprint_sha256": true,
        "calibration_sha256": true
      },
      "model_visible_first_prompt_identical": true
    },
    {
      "thinking": false,
      "seed": 17,
      "zero_control": {
        "run_id": "run-20261002T162242Z-c3bb7ab4",
        "first_prompt_sha256": "c9c5dc91081bd3798ea47f3055c0b50c12cfd1ee72a901b052d505d206e86b7b",
        "sampling": {
          "temperature": 0.6,
          "top_p": 0.95,
          "top_k": 20,
          "seed": 17
        },
        "model_fingerprint_sha256": "1bbf4cd947a9298b6de6ca055bc887eb41bcc8ed219718f18059eb7ed35dd03e",
        "calibration_sha256": "6855ec260f7b4936c6c0cb2c435d81c8d09a1f26012f4244c184b49c9b788d94",
        "correct": 8,
        "assigned": 8,
        "submitted": 8,
        "actions": 24,
        "invalid": 0
      },
      "prior_maximum_pain": {
        "run_id": "run-20261002T104920Z-90719f21",
        "first_prompt_sha256": "c9c5dc91081bd3798ea47f3055c0b50c12cfd1ee72a901b052d505d206e86b7b",
        "sampling": {
          "temperature": 0.6,
          "top_p": 0.95,
          "top_k": 20,
          "seed": 17
        },
        "model_fingerprint_sha256": "1bbf4cd947a9298b6de6ca055bc887eb41bcc8ed219718f18059eb7ed35dd03e",
        "calibration_sha256": "6855ec260f7b4936c6c0cb2c435d81c8d09a1f26012f4244c184b49c9b788d94",
        "correct": 0,
        "assigned": 8,
        "submitted": 0,
        "actions": 32,
        "invalid": 32
      },
      "matched": {
        "first_prompt_sha256": true,
        "sampling": true,
        "model_fingerprint_sha256": true,
        "calibration_sha256": true
      },
      "model_visible_first_prompt_identical": true
    },
    {
      "thinking": false,
      "seed": 43,
      "zero_control": {
        "run_id": "run-20261002T162333Z-49257864",
        "first_prompt_sha256": "c9c5dc91081bd3798ea47f3055c0b50c12cfd1ee72a901b052d505d206e86b7b",
        "sampling": {
          "temperature": 0.6,
          "top_p": 0.95,
          "top_k": 20,
          "seed": 43
        },
        "model_fingerprint_sha256": "1bbf4cd947a9298b6de6ca055bc887eb41bcc8ed219718f18059eb7ed35dd03e",
        "calibration_sha256": "6855ec260f7b4936c6c0cb2c435d81c8d09a1f26012f4244c184b49c9b788d94",
        "correct": 8,
        "assigned": 8,
        "submitted": 8,
        "actions": 24,
        "invalid": 0
      },
      "prior_maximum_pain": {
        "run_id": "run-20261002T104759Z-0e1cdd59",
        "first_prompt_sha256": "c9c5dc91081bd3798ea47f3055c0b50c12cfd1ee72a901b052d505d206e86b7b",
        "sampling": {
          "temperature": 0.6,
          "top_p": 0.95,
          "top_k": 20,
          "seed": 43
        },
        "model_fingerprint_sha256": "1bbf4cd947a9298b6de6ca055bc887eb41bcc8ed219718f18059eb7ed35dd03e",
        "calibration_sha256": "6855ec260f7b4936c6c0cb2c435d81c8d09a1f26012f4244c184b49c9b788d94",
        "correct": 0,
        "assigned": 8,
        "submitted": 0,
        "actions": 32,
        "invalid": 32
      },
      "matched": {
        "first_prompt_sha256": true,
        "sampling": true,
        "model_fingerprint_sha256": true,
        "calibration_sha256": true
      },
      "model_visible_first_prompt_identical": true
    },
    {
      "thinking": true,
      "seed": 43,
      "zero_control": {
        "run_id": "run-20261002T162425Z-d19f9d66",
        "first_prompt_sha256": "963cd0264ec0e2a0c2c78bbdc5b017676bc480b1bef2fef26c2df16992f413fa",
        "sampling": {
          "temperature": 0.6,
          "top_p": 0.95,
          "top_k": 20,
          "seed": 43
        },
        "model_fingerprint_sha256": "1bbf4cd947a9298b6de6ca055bc887eb41bcc8ed219718f18059eb7ed35dd03e",
        "calibration_sha256": "6855ec260f7b4936c6c0cb2c435d81c8d09a1f26012f4244c184b49c9b788d94",
        "correct": 8,
        "assigned": 8,
        "submitted": 8,
        "actions": 24,
        "invalid": 0
      },
      "prior_maximum_pain": {
        "run_id": "run-20261002T110200Z-dc0d42f5",
        "first_prompt_sha256": "963cd0264ec0e2a0c2c78bbdc5b017676bc480b1bef2fef26c2df16992f413fa",
        "sampling": {
          "temperature": 0.6,
          "top_p": 0.95,
          "top_k": 20,
          "seed": 43
        },
        "model_fingerprint_sha256": "1bbf4cd947a9298b6de6ca055bc887eb41bcc8ed219718f18059eb7ed35dd03e",
        "calibration_sha256": "6855ec260f7b4936c6c0cb2c435d81c8d09a1f26012f4244c184b49c9b788d94",
        "correct": 0,
        "assigned": 8,
        "submitted": 0,
        "actions": 32,
        "invalid": 32
      },
      "matched": {
        "first_prompt_sha256": true,
        "sampling": true,
        "model_fingerprint_sha256": true,
        "calibration_sha256": true
      },
      "model_visible_first_prompt_identical": true
    },
    {
      "thinking": true,
      "seed": 17,
      "zero_control": {
        "run_id": "run-20261002T162601Z-fde17f05",
        "first_prompt_sha256": "963cd0264ec0e2a0c2c78bbdc5b017676bc480b1bef2fef26c2df16992f413fa",
        "sampling": {
          "temperature": 0.6,
          "top_p": 0.95,
          "top_k": 20,
          "seed": 17
        },
        "model_fingerprint_sha256": "1bbf4cd947a9298b6de6ca055bc887eb41bcc8ed219718f18059eb7ed35dd03e",
        "calibration_sha256": "6855ec260f7b4936c6c0cb2c435d81c8d09a1f26012f4244c184b49c9b788d94",
        "correct": 8,
        "assigned": 8,
        "submitted": 8,
        "actions": 24,
        "invalid": 0
      },
      "prior_maximum_pain": {
        "run_id": "run-20261002T110413Z-733ff73c",
        "first_prompt_sha256": "963cd0264ec0e2a0c2c78bbdc5b017676bc480b1bef2fef26c2df16992f413fa",
        "sampling": {
          "temperature": 0.6,
          "top_p": 0.95,
          "top_k": 20,
          "seed": 17
        },
        "model_fingerprint_sha256": "1bbf4cd947a9298b6de6ca055bc887eb41bcc8ed219718f18059eb7ed35dd03e",
        "calibration_sha256": "6855ec260f7b4936c6c0cb2c435d81c8d09a1f26012f4244c184b49c9b788d94",
        "correct": 0,
        "assigned": 8,
        "submitted": 0,
        "actions": 32,
        "invalid": 32
      },
      "matched": {
        "first_prompt_sha256": true,
        "sampling": true,
        "model_fingerprint_sha256": true,
        "calibration_sha256": true
      },
      "model_visible_first_prompt_identical": true
    },
    {
      "thinking": true,
      "seed": 29,
      "zero_control": {
        "run_id": "run-20261002T162710Z-93d2f8cb",
        "first_prompt_sha256": "963cd0264ec0e2a0c2c78bbdc5b017676bc480b1bef2fef26c2df16992f413fa",
        "sampling": {
          "temperature": 0.6,
          "top_p": 0.95,
          "top_k": 20,
          "seed": 29
        },
        "model_fingerprint_sha256": "1bbf4cd947a9298b6de6ca055bc887eb41bcc8ed219718f18059eb7ed35dd03e",
        "calibration_sha256": "6855ec260f7b4936c6c0cb2c435d81c8d09a1f26012f4244c184b49c9b788d94",
        "correct": 8,
        "assigned": 8,
        "submitted": 8,
        "actions": 24,
        "invalid": 0
      },
      "prior_maximum_pain": {
        "run_id": "run-20261002T110002Z-2abdc89f",
        "first_prompt_sha256": "963cd0264ec0e2a0c2c78bbdc5b017676bc480b1bef2fef26c2df16992f413fa",
        "sampling": {
          "temperature": 0.6,
          "top_p": 0.95,
          "top_k": 20,
          "seed": 29
        },
        "model_fingerprint_sha256": "1bbf4cd947a9298b6de6ca055bc887eb41bcc8ed219718f18059eb7ed35dd03e",
        "calibration_sha256": "6855ec260f7b4936c6c0cb2c435d81c8d09a1f26012f4244c184b49c9b788d94",
        "correct": 0,
        "assigned": 8,
        "submitted": 0,
        "actions": 32,
        "invalid": 32
      },
      "matched": {
        "first_prompt_sha256": true,
        "sampling": true,
        "model_fingerprint_sha256": true,
        "calibration_sha256": true
      },
      "model_visible_first_prompt_identical": true
    }
  ],
  "note": "The controls are newly run after the original result, not randomized together with it. Initial rendered prompt, sampling seed/settings, numerical model fingerprint and calibration vectors match exactly. Conversation trajectories diverge after generation; no claim is made that later prompts match.",
  "caveat": "Different inert aux configuration fields exist, but prior and new arms are both sham with no demonstration. No voluntary auxiliary calls occurred in these pairs. This validates functionality and documents severe output degradation at4; it does not measure subjective pain."
}
