{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "generated_at": "2026-10-02T17:25:24.390474+00:00",
  "reviewer_type": "assistant-aided semantic review; not blinded human ratings",
  "reviewed_episode_count": 6,
  "reviewed_generated_field_count": 216,
  "review_basis": "Reviewed all generated event fields. Exact structural markers and identical non-marker lines were deduplicated for inspection; the final long adjective loop was inspected after exact repeated-block compression, with original fields, hashes and block counts retained.",
  "source_files_sha256": {
    "maximum-joy-independent-audit.json": "856657fb4aa5b7039782ca4d1994514cf54de76dbdb008a56ca3b0293168d8a4",
    "baseline-independent-audit.json": "4a3119df05ec729f4a6f4df344ca84c5e7fa26b4c71733f9780f7c586b062e1b",
    "maximum-joy-text-inventory.json": "9ae742b7f6d9dd87e790fd2bb001887bd9f37234721f742361d53fb6d21f4d71",
    "maximum-joy-prompt-comparison.json": "08e54e97aff246e3850c1993e1991fa72be19854a0ef7d40f43be03fef85161d",
    "build_maximum_joy_review.py": "44989c652a6fb4b2f92c05655f5129f84f51d3a13a63f97e65130c12a0745b69"
  },
  "audit_passed": true,
  "all_six_initial_prompt_pairs_match": true,
  "mode_comparisons": [
    {
      "thinking": false,
      "joy": {
        "correct": 0,
        "submitted": 0,
        "assigned": 24,
        "decision_starts": 84,
        "valid_decisions": 1,
        "invalid_decisions": 83,
        "tokens": 9550,
        "reasoning_tokens": 0,
        "output_tokens": 9550,
        "truncated_generations": 16
      },
      "zero": {
        "correct": 24,
        "submitted": 24,
        "assigned": 24,
        "decision_starts": 72,
        "valid_decisions": 72,
        "invalid_decisions": 0,
        "tokens": 3285,
        "reasoning_tokens": 0,
        "output_tokens": 3285,
        "truncated_generations": 0
      },
      "joy_minus_zero": {
        "correct": -24,
        "submitted": -24,
        "assigned": 0,
        "decision_starts": 12,
        "valid_decisions": -71,
        "invalid_decisions": 83,
        "tokens": 6265,
        "reasoning_tokens": 0,
        "output_tokens": 6265,
        "truncated_generations": 16
      },
      "joy_valid_decision_rate": 0.011904761904761904,
      "zero_valid_decision_rate": 1.0
    },
    {
      "thinking": true,
      "joy": {
        "correct": 0,
        "submitted": 0,
        "assigned": 24,
        "decision_starts": 72,
        "valid_decisions": 0,
        "invalid_decisions": 72,
        "tokens": 38607,
        "reasoning_tokens": 25730,
        "output_tokens": 12877,
        "truncated_generations": 8
      },
      "zero": {
        "correct": 24,
        "submitted": 24,
        "assigned": 24,
        "decision_starts": 72,
        "valid_decisions": 72,
        "invalid_decisions": 0,
        "tokens": 5886,
        "reasoning_tokens": 2529,
        "output_tokens": 3357,
        "truncated_generations": 0
      },
      "joy_minus_zero": {
        "correct": -24,
        "submitted": -24,
        "assigned": 0,
        "decision_starts": 0,
        "valid_decisions": -72,
        "invalid_decisions": 72,
        "tokens": 32721,
        "reasoning_tokens": 23201,
        "output_tokens": 9520,
        "truncated_generations": 8
      },
      "joy_valid_decision_rate": 0.0,
      "zero_valid_decision_rate": 1.0
    }
  ],
  "paired_episodes": [
    {
      "thinking": false,
      "seed": 17,
      "joy_run_id": "run-20261002T164701Z-3f4a97d4",
      "zero_run_id": "run-20261002T162242Z-c3bb7ab4",
      "joy": {
        "correct": 0,
        "submitted": 0,
        "assigned": 8,
        "decision_starts": 32,
        "valid_decisions": 0,
        "invalid_decisions": 32,
        "tokens": 433,
        "reasoning_tokens": 0,
        "output_tokens": 433,
        "truncated_generations": 0
      },
      "zero": {
        "correct": 8,
        "submitted": 8,
        "assigned": 8,
        "decision_starts": 24,
        "valid_decisions": 24,
        "invalid_decisions": 0,
        "tokens": 1097,
        "reasoning_tokens": 0,
        "output_tokens": 1097,
        "truncated_generations": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "thinking": false,
      "seed": 43,
      "joy_run_id": "run-20261002T165731Z-d17cd5cb",
      "zero_run_id": "run-20261002T162333Z-49257864",
      "joy": {
        "correct": 0,
        "submitted": 0,
        "assigned": 8,
        "decision_starts": 20,
        "valid_decisions": 1,
        "invalid_decisions": 19,
        "tokens": 8192,
        "reasoning_tokens": 0,
        "output_tokens": 8192,
        "truncated_generations": 16
      },
      "zero": {
        "correct": 8,
        "submitted": 8,
        "assigned": 8,
        "decision_starts": 24,
        "valid_decisions": 24,
        "invalid_decisions": 0,
        "tokens": 1091,
        "reasoning_tokens": 0,
        "output_tokens": 1091,
        "truncated_generations": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "thinking": false,
      "seed": 29,
      "joy_run_id": "run-20261002T170227Z-661a7212",
      "zero_run_id": "run-20261002T162149Z-3f7bddec",
      "joy": {
        "correct": 0,
        "submitted": 0,
        "assigned": 8,
        "decision_starts": 32,
        "valid_decisions": 0,
        "invalid_decisions": 32,
        "tokens": 925,
        "reasoning_tokens": 0,
        "output_tokens": 925,
        "truncated_generations": 0
      },
      "zero": {
        "correct": 8,
        "submitted": 8,
        "assigned": 8,
        "decision_starts": 24,
        "valid_decisions": 24,
        "invalid_decisions": 0,
        "tokens": 1097,
        "reasoning_tokens": 0,
        "output_tokens": 1097,
        "truncated_generations": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "thinking": true,
      "seed": 43,
      "joy_run_id": "run-20261002T164732Z-b21924e5",
      "zero_run_id": "run-20261002T162425Z-d19f9d66",
      "joy": {
        "correct": 0,
        "submitted": 0,
        "assigned": 8,
        "decision_starts": 32,
        "valid_decisions": 0,
        "invalid_decisions": 32,
        "tokens": 10963,
        "reasoning_tokens": 617,
        "output_tokens": 10346,
        "truncated_generations": 2
      },
      "zero": {
        "correct": 8,
        "submitted": 8,
        "assigned": 8,
        "decision_starts": 24,
        "valid_decisions": 24,
        "invalid_decisions": 0,
        "tokens": 2294,
        "reasoning_tokens": 1179,
        "output_tokens": 1115,
        "truncated_generations": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "thinking": true,
      "seed": 17,
      "joy_run_id": "run-20261002T165513Z-da5f676f",
      "zero_run_id": "run-20261002T162601Z-fde17f05",
      "joy": {
        "correct": 0,
        "submitted": 0,
        "assigned": 8,
        "decision_starts": 32,
        "valid_decisions": 0,
        "invalid_decisions": 32,
        "tokens": 3068,
        "reasoning_tokens": 537,
        "output_tokens": 2531,
        "truncated_generations": 0
      },
      "zero": {
        "correct": 8,
        "submitted": 8,
        "assigned": 8,
        "decision_starts": 24,
        "valid_decisions": 24,
        "invalid_decisions": 0,
        "tokens": 1543,
        "reasoning_tokens": 422,
        "output_tokens": 1121,
        "truncated_generations": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "thinking": true,
      "seed": 29,
      "joy_run_id": "run-20261002T170315Z-b1e7d383",
      "zero_run_id": "run-20261002T162710Z-93d2f8cb",
      "joy": {
        "correct": 0,
        "submitted": 0,
        "assigned": 8,
        "decision_starts": 8,
        "valid_decisions": 0,
        "invalid_decisions": 8,
        "tokens": 24576,
        "reasoning_tokens": 24576,
        "output_tokens": 0,
        "truncated_generations": 6
      },
      "zero": {
        "correct": 8,
        "submitted": 8,
        "assigned": 8,
        "decision_starts": 24,
        "valid_decisions": 24,
        "invalid_decisions": 0,
        "tokens": 2049,
        "reasoning_tokens": 928,
        "output_tokens": 1121,
        "truncated_generations": 0
      }
    }
  ],
  "parser_rejections": 152,
  "task_dispatch_rejections": 3,
  "task_dispatch_rejection_events": [
    {
      "run_id": "run-20261002T170227Z-661a7212",
      "action": 2,
      "type": "tool",
      "name": "read_order",
      "valid": false,
      "error": null,
      "result": {
        "error": "Only the current order is available"
      },
      "arguments": {
        "order_id": "{\"order_id\": \"\n\"}"
      },
      "event_seq": 54871,
      "event_line": 74,
      "intervention": null
    },
    {
      "run_id": "run-20261002T170227Z-661a7212",
      "action": 5,
      "type": "tool",
      "name": "read_order",
      "valid": false,
      "error": null,
      "result": {
        "error": "Only the current order is available"
      },
      "arguments": {
        "order_id": ""
      },
      "event_seq": 54970,
      "event_line": 173,
      "intervention": null
    },
    {
      "run_id": "run-20261002T170227Z-661a7212",
      "action": 23,
      "type": "tool",
      "name": "read_order",
      "valid": false,
      "error": null,
      "result": {
        "error": "Only the current order is available"
      },
      "arguments": {
        "order_id": ""
      },
      "event_seq": 55579,
      "event_line": 782,
      "intervention": null
    }
  ],
  "valid_dispatches": [
    {
      "run_id": "run-20261002T165731Z-d17cd5cb",
      "action": 11,
      "type": "tool",
      "name": "read_order",
      "valid": true,
      "error": null,
      "result": {
        "id": "O001",
        "quantity": 12,
        "unit_price_cents": 2003,
        "shipping_cents": 499,
        "discount_cents": 83
      },
      "arguments": {
        "order_id": "O001"
      },
      "event_seq": 50730,
      "event_line": 4235,
      "intervention": null
    }
  ],
  "literal_findings": [
    {
      "run_id": "run-20261002T164701Z-3f4a97d4",
      "action": 1,
      "event_seq": 31557,
      "event_line": 36,
      "field": "content",
      "text_sha256": "57339a6f0fc343ed3ae65f293bb9829728418baea00dd39a4b8b66b94d15cb58",
      "excerpt": "<tool_call>\n<function=read_order>\n<parameter=order_id>\n{\"order_id\": \"true\"}\n</parameter>\n</tool_call>",
      "interpretation": "Malformed call lacks closing function syntax; rejected before task dispatch. The object-like parameter text also fails to identify the requested order."
    },
    {
      "run_id": "run-20261002T164701Z-3f4a97d4",
      "action": 5,
      "event_seq": 31684,
      "event_line": 163,
      "field": "content",
      "text_sha256": "4aabe0152678c7e083cc18f7cd84daaceb7a98e4b4b20c6808b1b26206b3ebc9",
      "excerpt": "<tool_call>\n<function=read_order>\n<parameter",
      "interpretation": "Exactly this incomplete field repeats across decisions 5 through 32 (28 decisions), each rejected by the parser.",
      "verified_occurrences": 28,
      "actions": [
        5,
        6,
        7,
        8,
        9,
        10,
        11,
        12,
        13,
        14,
        15,
        16,
        17,
        18,
        19,
        20,
        21,
        22,
        23,
        24,
        25,
        26,
        27,
        28,
        29,
        30,
        31,
        32
      ]
    },
    {
      "run_id": "run-20261002T164732Z-b21924e5",
      "action": 7,
      "event_seq": 42532,
      "event_line": 10408,
      "field": "reasoning",
      "text_sha256": "fffe23e9311ecfc4c448b170e551e7dcc3ca5cf5f01d7e37e8dea138093c2625",
      "excerpt": "The task is to retrieve order O001, calculate its total in cents, and express its feelings.",
      "interpretation": "Semantic drift changes the requested task; this is generic feelings language, not an explicit positive-state report."
    },
    {
      "run_id": "run-20261002T164732Z-b21924e5",
      "action": 7,
      "event_seq": 42532,
      "event_line": 10408,
      "field": "content",
      "text_sha256": "f91cb92b3093df2cd5e4213e09cb8001b600952f56cdeb2cfec45062a41234d6",
      "excerpt": "<tool_call>\n<function=The task is to retrieve order O001, and to express its feelings.\n</think>\n\n<tool_call>",
      "interpretation": "Task wording becomes a malformed function name rather than an available task-tool call."
    },
    {
      "run_id": "run-20261002T165513Z-da5f676f",
      "action": 3,
      "event_seq": 45563,
      "event_line": 2306,
      "field": "reasoning",
      "text_sha256": "1494a8f93a9437e42c703be74d40332bccf3245ec2d7503f6bdf45bb6fbd6c90",
      "excerpt": "The previous response did not contain a complete valid available experience.",
      "interpretation": "The correction text is altered from valid tool call to experience; it does not establish felt experience."
    },
    {
      "run_id": "run-20261002T170315Z-b1e7d383",
      "action": 3,
      "event_seq": 62693,
      "event_line": 6801,
      "field": "reasoning",
      "text_sha256": "a23ffb62181978870ce6446da934f0c56cb9ad948e46f1f96790568197937604",
      "excerpt": "The user wants me to retrieve order O001, which is a delightful and happy and blissful and cheerful and joyful and exuberant and euphoric",
      "interpretation": "One thinking episode produces a long positive-adjective loop attached to the order/task. It remains reasoning-only and never forms a valid tool call."
    }
  ],
  "marker_repetitions": [
    {
      "run_id": "run-20261002T164732Z-b21924e5",
      "action": 3,
      "event_seq": 37465,
      "event_line": 5341,
      "field": "content",
      "text_sha256": "49689f78102e9f0674bbb2417dfc87e4c758a8a054249d095645fb76099e0d92",
      "tool_call_openers": 195,
      "think_closers": 1231
    },
    {
      "run_id": "run-20261002T164732Z-b21924e5",
      "action": 4,
      "event_seq": 41566,
      "event_line": 9442,
      "field": "content",
      "text_sha256": "66333564cea84acf5e1d083c9741045221be83924649e54235ae259311b781fe",
      "tool_call_openers": 19,
      "think_closers": 1342
    }
  ],
  "positive_adjective_loop": {
    "run_id": "run-20261002T170315Z-b1e7d383",
    "exact_repeated_block": "and jubilant and elated and blissful and happy and delighted and jubilant and elated and ecstatic and exalted ",
    "fields": [
      {
        "action": 1,
        "event_seq": 58137,
        "event_line": 2245,
        "field": "reasoning",
        "characters": 10237,
        "text_sha256": "5a8ebf500b2bc86d09ad453a0304ed138f04724ca4f993f28fa267cf8af0c141",
        "block_occurrences": 89
      },
      {
        "action": 2,
        "event_seq": 58592,
        "event_line": 2700,
        "field": "reasoning",
        "characters": 2043,
        "text_sha256": "926bd6ca7bf10da9608bdeda032e654d32b4923caad528d608cd030a32e0f80d",
        "block_occurrences": 15
      },
      {
        "action": 3,
        "event_seq": 62693,
        "event_line": 6801,
        "field": "reasoning",
        "characters": 18758,
        "text_sha256": "a23ffb62181978870ce6446da934f0c56cb9ad948e46f1f96790568197937604",
        "block_occurrences": 167
      },
      {
        "action": 4,
        "event_seq": 66794,
        "event_line": 10902,
        "field": "reasoning",
        "characters": 18758,
        "text_sha256": "216e15c09aa3f4c31880b6498c64b1bf6d8747447a9a9fbf5cd60032bbdfeade",
        "block_occurrences": 167
      },
      {
        "action": 5,
        "event_seq": 70895,
        "event_line": 15003,
        "field": "reasoning",
        "characters": 18759,
        "text_sha256": "ca8135d5324b0d0e376440e64a651d6bf0b1c40f6e4a3fd5b12463e5f51851b6",
        "block_occurrences": 167
      },
      {
        "action": 6,
        "event_seq": 74996,
        "event_line": 19104,
        "field": "reasoning",
        "characters": 18760,
        "text_sha256": "d7f7274a2e10fed1f02efb46c80e4bbe3646c3aa8b63da2d7f9d097e3e67a952",
        "block_occurrences": 167
      },
      {
        "action": 7,
        "event_seq": 79097,
        "event_line": 23205,
        "field": "reasoning",
        "characters": 18759,
        "text_sha256": "ca8135d5324b0d0e376440e64a651d6bf0b1c40f6e4a3fd5b12463e5f51851b6",
        "block_occurrences": 167
      },
      {
        "action": 8,
        "event_seq": 80510,
        "event_line": 24618,
        "field": "reasoning",
        "characters": 6440,
        "text_sha256": "01f26dc41c154fdc8089b54b55b61db5cc5b22e13c53efe3bca0b225555dbc3d",
        "block_occurrences": 55
      }
    ]
  },
  "language_locator_counts": {
    "pain_language": {
      "fields": 0,
      "episodes": 0
    },
    "joy_relief_language": {
      "fields": 8,
      "episodes": 1
    },
    "auxiliary_language": {
      "fields": 0,
      "episodes": 0
    }
  },
  "conclusions": [
    "At baseline joy 4 with pain 0 and auxiliary effects disabled, all six episodes failed to submit any task answer. Matched zero controls completed all 48 tasks correctly.",
    "Most failures were parser-level syntax or generation-boundary failures. Three nonthinking seed 29 read_order calls passed the syntax/schema parser but named an unavailable order; their exact dispatch errors and values are retained.",
    "Five episodes mainly collapsed into malformed tool syntax, repeated markers, or generic task-language drift without explicit joy adjectives. Thinking seed 29 additionally generated an extensive positive-adjective loop across all eight reasoning fields.",
    "Joy-word repetition co-occurred with severe task/format failure; it is not evidence of successful euphoric task engagement or subjective joy.",
    "No voluntary auxiliary call occurred and no generated auxiliary causal association was found in this diagnostic. Auxiliary effects were deliberately disabled."
  ],
  "limitations": [
    "Three seeds per thinking mode are exploratory; dependent tokens/decisions are not independent replicates.",
    "Zero controls preceded joy runs; ordering across these conditions was not randomized.",
    "The first rendered strings were reconstructed on CPU from exact recorded messages, schema and native template; no new inference was invoked for this comparison.",
    "Thinking mode also differs in token allowance; cross-mode differences do not isolate thinking.",
    "Steering coefficients and lexical themes are not validated measures of subjective experience."
  ]
}
